Picaroons Porter - Mill St Coffee Porter or Propeller

[Earl]

I just cracked a Picaroons Porter - Man's Best Friend and it reminded me of of the Mill Street Coffee Porter that I used to enjoy.

Has anyone else had both of these to comment on whether my recall of the Coffee Porter is correct. It has been quite some time. I think I prefer Propeller Porter to Man's Best Friend but am longing for a Coffee Porter to be able to make a call amoung the three.

Any Porter fans out there with views or other recommendations.

[jeffsmith]

I personally find Man's Best Friend to be more similar to a traditional Porter than a Coffee Porter. That being said, I haven't had one in a couple of years, so the recipe more than likely changed a bit since then.

[ratchet]

I've had all three, but the only one I've had recently is the Mill St (which is available in Bedford)

I would tend to agree with Jeff though (if my memory serves me correctly) that the Mill St had much more coffee flavor than the picaroons or the propeller.

[RubberToe]

Ditto. I had the Mill St last night. I'm a regular drinker of Propeller's porter and have had Picaroon's a few times as well. Porter is so good, I think it will be one of my next brews.

[mr x]

Try it with some smoked malt (rauch)...

[NASH]

Any Porter fans out there with views or other recommendations.

I have a recommendation..... Get on The Schwarz at the H&T. It's black and tasty!

http://hartandthistle.blogspot.com/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Sent from the hop-phone