Garrison's 2012 Ultimate Brew-off Challenge

[know1]

I too, was not chosen!

However, I thankfully do enjoy both of my beer, cause I have a lot of it to drink!

Same here!

[chalmers]

A strike-out here too. Mine is growing on me, I didn't like it initially.

[whisle pig]

No for me as well, but more to drink!

[mr x]

Fuck, we're going down hard. Damn you Daniel *shakes fist* (we need a fist shaking smilie )

[BBrianBoogie]

In for the win baby

[mr x]

sweet

[homebrewcrew]

X did you win or in the top 4? I came in 62nd how many entries were there?

[mr x]

Didn't enter, so i finished worse than you.

[John G]

I got the rejection letter too. Now I have to find some friends who like rye beer.

[mr x]

Remember the 31st at my place.

[amartin]

I am also not in the top four, for the fourth year in a row. Oh well, I'll find it a good home.

[Tim Gregory]

Struck out again... Too bad, I had high hopes this year.

Congrats Brian!! Good luck!

[jeffsmith]

We got one no here in Amherst, just not sure which one. Hopeful for the other two entries!

[akr71]

A strike-out here too. Mine is growing on me, I didn't like it initially.

I got the rejection email too. For folks with multiple entries, did you get an email for each rejected entry?

[JohnnyMac]

Ahhhhhh....fuck. Just got my PFO email.

Well done Triple B!

[RobD]

A strike-out here too. Mine is growing on me, I didn't like it initially.

I got the rejection email too. For folks with multiple entries, did you get an email for each rejected entry?

2 entries, 1 rejection email for me.

[LiverDance]

I got my rejection email, still waiting to hear on JT and Anne though.

[akr71]

I just got another email from Garrison saying that the FOAD email does indeed apply to all 3 SAAZ entries.
I had high hopes for these beers this year. I wouldn't be surprised if brewing cost is a factor in the judging.

[mr x]

I wouldn't be surprised if every single thing other than how the beer tastes is a factor....

That's why we're doing our own on the 31st.

[LiverDance]

I just got another email from Garrison saying that the FOAD email does indeed apply to all 3 SAAZ entries.
I had high hopes for these beers this year. I wouldn't be surprised if brewing cost is a factor in the judging.

I had a good chat one time with Daniel about the process and it's completely blind to them. The entries are a number and they only look at the final four names and recipes after they are choosen. When I was dropping off my samples this year he wouldn't come near me, I had to go over and talk to him cause he didn't want to see what my bottles looked like just in case.

[jeffsmith]

I just got another email from Garrison saying that the FOAD email does indeed apply to all 3 SAAZ entries.
I had high hopes for these beers this year. I wouldn't be surprised if brewing cost is a factor in the judging.

That's too bad. I thought we had three pretty solid entries. Really surprised that your solo brew didn't make it in to be honest.

[Bryan]

Does anyone know if all 62 entries receive some sort of feedback ?

[mr x]

Unless things have changed, the score sheets for all beers are available for pickup on the 22nd.

[Bryan]

That's good to know... I should be in town for the 22nd event, and get to meet some of you fellow beer geeks.

[mr x]

Remember to bring a few of your beers if you have any left, we'd like them for the 31st. I'm still working on how to drop them off.